Last Thursday evening, one of our many oak trees fell on my Shaver 165 boiler. It has been in service 10-11 years. It is not damaged beyond repair, but is heavily damaged. My insurance company has stated they will replace it.
I buy my wood, so I am not getting "Free Heat". I have calculated in the past that propane needs to be around $1.20 per gal or less to be comparable to my wood costs for the season. My last full season use of propane was 1000 gal. I think that was before I insulated my floors. I have a farm house built in 1917. It is fairly energy efficient, except for the old double hung windows with storms over them.
Last summer, I had to repair a leak in the bottom of the water jacket. It appeared that other leaks may be over the horizon. I reworked the insulation and seals before last season, getting good burns throughout last winter. Probably the best I have ever gotten.
Since Shaver is gone, should I just take the money and run to my propane supplier, or should I look toward another boiler purchase? I know I keep my house a few degrees warmer with the boiler, than I did with the propane furnace. I also enjoy my endless supply of hot water. I tend to get fewer complaints from my wife and daughter when the hot water is in plenty supply. BTW, my propane furnace is approaching 15 years old, but has been used little since installing the Shaver 11 years ago.
Any advice on my next move?
Thanks