i think you have about 15 feet of head in the pipe of 160 feet. to get 8 gpm you would need (from the taco chart) an 0011 or 0013. this would put you about the middle of the pump curve (where you should be) and 8 GPM would give you (at 180 degree water) 80,000 btu per hour and that is likley near what your original home furnace is (just a guess) you can find that info on the name plate somewhere.
depending where you are and what your winters are like you can size yoru pump for how many GPM you need
every GPM at 180 delivers 10,000 btu to your home in you want only 6 GPM you can look on a pump flow chart for 15 feet of head at 6 GPM and aim to find that required GPM near the middle of the pumps flow chart (as stated before this head loss is only for the pipe not for inside the house or the loss at exchangers (that is a good reason to aim for the middle of the pumps flow chart or go up a foot or 2 of head
How did you come up with 15 feet of head at 8 gpm? Using this chart for 8 gpm you need to multiply the length by 0.140 then multiply by 2.307. My calculations come out to almost 52 feet of heat on 160'. Am I doing something wrong?
http://www.alliedpex.com/LITERATURES/PEX_Pressure_Drop_Table.pdf
Uh......... Gentlemen, you do know your using the wrong chart...right? That is a different head loss calculation, it doesn't figure friction head loss as a rate of flow. Combined it is called total dynamic head loss , And the more gpm you flow the head goes up exponentially. That chart is specifically for potable water supply lines ( toilets,faucets, etc) from a plumbing code book. 10 gpm at 180* supplies 100,000 btu/hr which is big enuff to heat some big homes. You need to look at a pump chart like this
http://www.taco-hvac.com/uploads/FileLibrary/SelectingCirculators.pdfBut before you do that, you need to know your heat load, how many BTU's you need all together. This will give you how many gpms you will need to flow. Also in that chart you will be able to see how much a 3/4 line can actually supply and whether you need to go larger or not. There is a reason 007,15-58 pumps are the most popular sizes, since they can supply over 150kbtu/hr on the right sized pipe. But if you exceed 10' head loss that 007 wont pump squat. Hopefully this helps a little