What do you guys think based on the pics? Does anyone see anything tharpt jumps out at them?
In regards to a tall chimey, there are members here with like15-20ft chimneys and they make em work fine, only thing I've ever saw a tall chimney hurt was make a small air leak a bigger problem
If your air is blowing in under the grates that's good, I assume you stir it around some so it dont get plugged up, that could cause that if it was totally clogged in the front and only open directly under the chimney...
Natures comfort has the drop chimey like yours that I'm familiar with. There air enters directly under the chimney and is allows to come up through only 3 slots, it works. So I dont know
Your firebox material looks really thick but you said it's only 1/4".
As far as the fire getting hotter when u open the door does tell us it needs air and that your air is going to the wrong place, I'd check to see if your grates are clogged